Potion Calls For	Acceptable Substitute
Acacia	Gum Arabic
Acacia, Gum	Gum Arabic
Aconite	Tobacco
Arabic, Gum	Frankincense Gum Mastic Gum Tragacanth (for binding wet ingredients, not for incense use)
Ammoniac, Gum	Asafoetida
Asafoetida	Tobacco Valerian
Balm of Gilead	Rose buds Gum Mastic
Bdellium, Gum	Copal Pine resin Dragon's Blood
Belladonna	Tobacco
Benzoin	Gum Arabic Gum Mastic
Cachana	Angelica root
Camphor Oil	Eucalyptus oil Lavender oil
Carnation	Rose petals annointed with a few drops of Clove oil
Cassia	Cinnamon (Cinnamon sold in the US is actually the less expensive Cassia.)
Castor Bean	a few drops of Castor oil
Cedar	Sandalwood
Cinquefoil	Clover Trefoil
Citron	equal parts Orange peel and Lemon peel
Clove	Mace Nutmeg
Clover	Cinquefoil
Copal	Frankincense Cedar
Cowbane	Tobacco
Cypress	Juniper Pine needles
Deerstongue	Tonka bean (not for internal use) Woodruff Vanilla
Dittany of Crete	Gum Mastic
Dragon's Blood	equal parts Frankincense and Red Sandalwood
Eucalyptus oil	Camphor oil Lavender oil
Euphorbium	Tobacco
Frankincense	Copal Pine resin
Galangal	Ginger root
Grains of Paradise	Black Pepper
Hellebore	Tobacco Nettle
Hemlock	Tobacco
Hemp	Nutmeg Damiana Star Anise Bay
Henbane	Tobacco
Hyssop	Lavender
Ivy	Cinquefoil
Jasmine	Rose
Juniper	Pine
Lavender	Rose
Lemongrass	Lemon peel
Lemon peel	Lemongrass Lemon Verbena
Lemon Verbena	Lemongrass Lemon peel
Mace	Nutmeg
Mandrake	Tobacco
Mastic, Gum	Gum Arabic Frankincense
Mint (any type)	Sage
Mistletoe	Mint Sage
Mugwort	Wormwood
Neroli oil	Orange oil
Nightshade	Tobacco
Nutmeg	Mace Cinnamon
Oakmoss	Patchouly
Orange	Tangerine peel
Orange flowers	Orange peel
Patchouly	Oakmoss
Peppermint	Spearmint
Pepperwort	Rue Grains of Paradise Black Pepper
Pine	Juniper
Pine resin	Frankincense Copal
Red Sandalwood	Sandalwood mixed with a pinch of Dragon's Blood
Rose	Yarrow
Rose Geranium	Rose
Rue	Rosemary mixed with a pinch of Black Pepper
Saffron	Orange peel
Sandalwood	Cedar
Sarasparilla	Sassafras
Sassafras	Sarasparilla
Spearmint	Peppermint
Sulfur	Tobacco Club Moss Asafoetida
Thyme	Rosemary
Tobacco	Bay
Tonka bean	Deerstonge Woodruff Vanilla bean
Trefoil	Cinquefoil
Valerian	Asafoetida
Vanilla	Woodruff Deerstongue Tonka bean
Vetivert	Calamus
Wolfsbane	Tobacco
Wood Aloe	Sandalwood sprinkled with Ambergris oil
Woodruff	Deerstongue Vanilla
Wormwood	Mugwort
Yarrow	Rose
Yew	Tobacco